Volume 4
Commentary-Special Issue(Deepening of Disciplinary Content: Public Health in Post-Covid India)

A Complex Systems Account of the Covid-19 Pandemic: Illustrations from India

pdf
  • Sayan Das
Sayan Das
Research Scholar, Centre of Social Medicine and Community Health, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India

Published 2023-09-02

Keywords

  • Sars-cov-2, Complex Adaptive Systems, Covid-19 Treatment, Migrant Crisis, Complexity And Health, Steroids

How to Cite

Das, S. (2023). A Complex Systems Account of the Covid-19 Pandemic: Illustrations from India. DIALOGUE: Science, Scientists and Society, 4(.), 1–13. Retrieved from https://dialogue.ias.ac.in/index.php/dialogue/article/view/22

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic in India and the rest of the world was followed by tremendous health and social consequences. Worldwide the pandemic created challenges that were unpredictable and elusive to our existing ways of thinking. The paper posits that a complex systems thinking is needed to make sense of the society-wide ramifications of a ‘wicked’ problem like the pandemic and devise appropriate resolutions. A complex systems thinking conceptualizes our society as emergent from irreducible interdependencies across individuals, communities and systems, and the pandemic as a complex systems problem that has consequences both immediate and future. The paper uses the complexity lens to explore the unanticipated repercussions of the pandemic control measures that further accentuated pandemic induced socio-economic disruptions, and secondly, the domain of COVID-19 treatment in India, as examples, to demonstrate that while devising a response to complex phenomena like the pandemic more needs to be accounted for than what meets the eye. It thus calls for a more caring science that understands and respects our shared existence and wellbeing and makes use of diverse, democratic and decentralised processes to forge shared pathways for navigating our complex world.

pdf

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

  1. Azim Premji University. 2021 State of Working India 2021: One year of Covid-19. Centre for Sustainable Employment, Azim Premji University, Bengaluru, India.
  2. Gupta A 2021. Beyond Covid: We must address the hunger crisis in India. The Indian Express, New Delhi, India. https:// indianexpress.com/ article/ opinion/ columns/ coronanvirus-indiasecondwave-hunger-index-poverty-migrant-crisis-7323648/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 3. Priya R and Das S 2020. The Blind Spots of Public Health. The India Forum, India. Url: https:// www.theindiaforum.in/ article/ blind-spots-public-health [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 4. Scoones I 2020. Pandemics: Why a new science is needed. ESRC STEPS Centre, Sussex, UK.
  3. https:// steps-centre.org/ blog/ pandemics-why-a-new-science-is-needed/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 5. The Health Foundation. 2010 Evidence scan: Complex adaptive systems. The Health Foundation, UK.
  4. Rittel H W and Webber M M 1973. Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), pp.155-169.
  5. Waltner-Toews D 2020a. On pandemics: deadly diseases from bubonic plague to coronavirus, p.127. Greystone Books Ltd, Vancouver, Canada.
  6. Rickles D, Hawe P and Shiell A 2007. A simple guide to chaos and complexity. Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, 61(11), pp.933-937.
  7. Morin E 1992. From the concept of system to the paradigm of complexity. Journal of social and evolutionary systems, 15(4), pp. 371-385.
  8. Indian Public Health Association., Indian Association of Preventive and Social Medicine., and Indian Association of Epidemiologists. 2020 Second Joint Statement on COVID-19 Pandemic in India – Public Health Approach for COVID-19 Control. https:// www.iphaonline.org/ wpcontent/ uploads/ 2020/ 06/ Second-Joint-Statement-of-IPHA-IAPSM-and-IAE-on-COVID-19containment-plan-May-25-2020_Final.pdf [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 11. Ghoshal D and Das K 2021. Scientists say India government ignored warnings amid coronavirussurge. Reuters. https:// www.reuters.com/ world/ asia-pacific/ exclusive-scientists-say-indiagovernmentignored-warnings-amid-coronavirus-2021-05-01/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 12. Paina L. and Peters D.H. 2012 Understanding pathways for scaling up health services through the lens of complex adaptive systems. Health policy and planning, 27(5), pp.365-373.
  9. Islam M S, Sarkar T, Khan S H, Kamal A H M, Hasan S M, Kabir A et al. 2020. COVID-19– related infodemic and its impact on public health: A global social media analysis. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 103(4), p.1621.
  10. Sturmberg J P 2014. Emergent properties define the subjective nature of health and dis-ease.
  11. Journal of public health policy, 35(3), pp.414-419.
  12. Dhume S 2021. Modi Declared Victory, Then Covid Struck Back With a Vengeance. The Wall Street Journal, USA. https:// www.wsj.com/ articles/ modi-declared-victory-then-covid-struckbackwith-a-vengeance-11620922164 [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 16. National Institutes of Health. 2020 Covid-19 treatment guidelines: Corticosteroids. National Institutes of Health, USA. https:// www.covid19treatmentguidelines.nih.gov/ immunomodulators/ corticosteroids/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 17. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. 2021a CLINICAL GUIDANCE FOR MANAGEMENT OF ADULT COVID-19 PATIENTS [May 17, 2021] Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, India. https:// covid.aiims.edu/ clinical-guidance-for-management-of-adult-covid-19-patients/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 18. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. 2021b CLINICAL GUIDANCE FOR MANAGEMENT OF ADULT COVID-19 PATIENTS [May 17, 2021] Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, India. https:// covid.aiims.edu/ clinical-guidance-for-management-of-adult-covid-19-patients/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 19. All India Institute of Medical Sciences. 2021 Covid-19 infection and Rhino-orbital-cerebral Mucormycosis Treatment Organization and Guidance. All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India. Url: https:// covid.aiims.edu/ mucormycosis-in-covid-19/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 20. Mordani S 2021. Probe link between Black Fungus, use of zinc in treatment of Covid patients: Experts. India Today, New Delhi, India. https:// www.indiatoday.in/ coronavirus-outbreak/ story/ black-fungus-mucormycosis-cases-epidemic-zinc-treatment-covid-experts-1805824-2021-05-22 [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021] 21. Patel A, Agarwal R, Rudramurthy S M, Shevkani M, Xess I, Sharma R et al. 2021. Multicenter Epidemiologic Study of Coronavirus Disease-Associated Mucormycosis, India. Emerg Infect Dis,27(9), Epub ahead of print.
  13. Rawson T M, Moore L S, Zhu N, Ranganathan N, Skolimowska K, Gilchrist M et al. 2020.
  14. Bacterial and fungal coinfection in individuals with coronavirus: a rapid review to support COVID-19 antimicrobial prescribing. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 71(9), pp. 2459-2468.
  15. Nori P, Cowman K, Chen V, Bartash R, Szymczak W, Madaline T et al. 2020. Bacterial and fungal coinfections in COVID-19 patients hospitalized during the New York City pandemic surge. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, pp.1-5.
  16. Ganguly N K 2021. Antimicrobial Resistance Is a Serious Threat To Public Health in India. The Wire, India. https:// science.thewire.in/ health/ antimicrobial-resistance-is-a-serious-threat-topublichealth-in-india/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021]
  17. Kaur B and Kapil S 2021. Why experts are not happy with India’s COVID-19 vaccine
  18. procurement, pricing policy. Down To Earth, India. https:// www.downtoearth.org.in/ news/
  19. health/ why-experts-are-not-happy-with-india-s-covid-19-vaccine-procurement-pricing-policy-
  20. [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021]
  21. Chowdhury R D 2021. Modi Never Bought Enough COVID-19 Vaccines for India. Now the
  22. Whole World Is Paying. Time magazine, USA. https:// time.com/ 6052370/ modi-didnt-buyenough-
  23. covid-19-vaccine/ [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021]
  24. Zhang E J, Aitchison L P, Phillips N, Shaban R Z and Kam A W 2021. Protecting the
  25. environment from plastic PPE. BMJ, UK.
  26. Waltner-Toews D, Biggeri A, De Marchi B, Funtowicz S, Giampietro M, O'Connor M et al.
  27. b. Post-normal pandemics: Why CoViD-19 requires a new approach to science. Recenti
  28. progressi in medicina, 111(4).
  29. Das S 2020. Why Preparations for the Next Pandemic Must Begin Now. The Wire, India.
  30. https:// science.thewire.in/ health/ covid-19-next-pandemic-prepare-ihr-2005-ayushman-bharat/
  31. [accessed on: 06/ 06/ 2021]
  32. Stevens J P, O’Donoghue A, Horng S, Tandon M and Tabb K 2020. Healthcare’s earthquake:
  33. Lessons from complex adaptive systems to develop Covid-19-responsive measures and models.
  34. NEJM Catalyst Innovations in Care Delivery, 1(5).
  35. Lancet T 2020. Zoonoses: Beyond the Human-Animal-Environment Interface. The Lancet.
  36. Nayar K R 2013. Universalizing health services in India: The techno-managerial fix. Indian
  37. journal of public health, 57(4), p.248.
  38. Loewenson R., Colvin C.J., Szabzon F., Das S., Khanna R., Coelho V.S.P. et al. 2021 Beyond
  39. command and control: A rapid review of meaningful community-engaged responses to
  40. COVID-19. Global Public Health, pp.1-15.
  41. Tiwari P, Das S and Aich U 2020. How To Tap Community Participation To Defeat COVID-19.
  42. India Spend, India. https:// www.indiaspend.com/ how-to-tap-community-participation-todefeat-
  43. covid-19/ [accessed on 12/ 07/ 2021]