Published 2023-09-03
Keywords
- Net neutrality; clicktivism; Save the internet
How to Cite
Abstract
In March 2015, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) released a consultation paper inviting responses and comments from the public to recommendations that private telecom operators be allowed to charge extra for third-party internet-based applications and services. This was in response to certain telecom companies deciding to charge internet-based voice calls at the rate of voice calls, paving the way for differentiating between kinds of content transferred via the internet using mobile phones. In response, an unprecedented online movement inundated the TRAI website, seeking to overturn the recommendations, and laying the groundwork for what has come to be seen as robust net neutrality laws.
The movement was magnified online by a group of artists, journalists, technologists, lawyers, and policy experts who came together under the Save The Internet campaign and encouraged internet users in India to take part in the consultation process. TRAI received over a million responses. It was this public outcry that defeated some of the most powerful players in the digital realm – from telecom companies to Facebook, leading to the net neutrality laws that now exist in India.
This paper will attempt to chart the evolution of net neutrality in India, focusing on how the net neutrality regulations came to be. In so doing, the paper hopes to understand how a leaderless citizen movement helped shape policy within a highly technical space, normally considered the domain of ‘experts.’ As more and more ‘users’ of the internet are transformed into ‘consumers’ of internet-related products, the lines demarcating ‘consumers,’ ‘citizens,’ ‘users,’ and ‘data subjects’ are becoming increasingly blurred. In moments such as the public debate on net neutrality, not only did the ‘citizen’ aspect of internet users come to the fore, it also allowed for the observation of participatory democracy in action.
Downloads
Metrics
References
- BBC News. 2018, July 12. India adopts ‘world’s strongest’ net neutrality norms. BBC News. https:// www.bbc.com/ news/ world-asia-india-44796436
- Statista. 2020b. Most internet users by country. Statista. https:// www.statista.com/ statistics/ 262966/ number-of-internet-users-in-selected-countries/
- Statista. 2020a. India—Internet penetration rate 2020. Statista. https:// www.statista.com/ statistics/ 792074/ india-internet-penetration-rate/
- Wu, T. 2003. Network Neutrality, Broadband Discrimination. Journal of Telecommunications and High Technology Law, 2, 141.
- Young, L. 2016, August 16. The Battle Over Net Neutrality Started With the 1920s-Era ‘Hush-APhone’. Atlas Obscura. http:// www.atlasobscura.com/ articles/ the-battle-over-net-neutralitystarted- with-the-1920s-era-hushaphone
- Popular Mechanics. (1941, February). Voice Silencer on Telephone Lets You Talk in Secret— Popular Mechanics (Feb, 1941). Modern Mechanix. http:// blog.modernmechanix.com/ voicesilencer- on-telephone-lets-you-talk-in-secret/
- Wu, T. 2010. The Master Switch: The Rise and Fall of Information Empires. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. https:// books.google.co.in/ books?id=6Dp4FoEEo6IC
- FCC. 2010, December 23. Preserving the Open Internet; Final rule. Federal Communications Commission. https:// www.fcc.gov/ document/ preserving-open-internet-final-rule
- Hush-A-Phone Corporation v. United States, 238 F.2d 266 (United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit 8 November 1956). https:// casetext.com/ case/ hush-a-phonecorporation- v-united-states
- Lasar, M. 2017, December 13. Any lawful device: Revisiting Carterfone on the eve of the Net Neutrality vote. Ars Technica. https:// arstechnica.com/ tech-policy/ 2017/ 12/ carterfone-40-years/
- Dixit, P. 2014, December 24. Airtel wants you to pay extra for using Skype, Viber, more. https:// www.hindustantimes.com/ tech/ airtel-wants-you-to-pay-extra-for-using-skype-viber-more/ story-wdKf8Xpbo9jZMdcboyFrzK.html
- Gustin, S. 2010, December 21. FCC Passes Compromise Net Neutrality Rules | WIRED. Wired. https:// www.wired.com/ 2010/ 12/ fcc-order/
- Last Week Tonight, H. 2014, June 1. Net Neutrality: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)— YouTube [YouTube]. Net Neutrality: Last Week Tonight With John Oliver (HBO). https:// www.youtube.com/ watch?v=fpbOEoRrHyU
- McDonald, S. N. 2014, June 4. John Oliver’s net neutrality rant may have caused FCC site crash. Washington Post. https:// www.washingtonpost.com/ news/ morning-mix/ wp/ 2014/ 06/ 04/ john-olivers-net-neutrality-rant-may-have-caused-fcc-site-crash/
- Bhatia, R. 2016, May 12. The inside story of Facebook’s biggest setback | Rahul Bhatia. The Guardian. https:// www.theguardian.com/ technology/ 2016/ may/ 12/ facebook-free-basics-indiazuckerberg
- Constine, J. 2013, August 21. Facebook And 6 Phone Companies Launch Internet.org To Bring Affordable Access To Everyone. TechCrunch. http:// social.techcrunch.com/ 2013/ 08/ 20/ facebook-internet-org/
- Schroeder, S. 2013, August 21. Mark Zuckerberg Aims to Bring Net Access to Everyone With Internet.org. Mashable. https:// mashable.com/ 2013/ 08/ 21/ mark-zuckerberg-internet-org/
- Vincent, J. 2015, May 4. Facebook invites everyone inside its Internet.org walled garden. The Verge. https:// www.theverge.com/ 2015/ 5/4/ 8542131/ interner-org-net-neutrality-platformdevelopers
- Sharma, R. 2014, December 9. Mark Zuckerberg’s Chandauli Visit Was Part Of His Bigger Plan To Connect The World. Business Insider. https:// www.businessinsider.in/ mark-zuckerbergschandauli- visit-was-part-of-his-bigger-plan-to-connect-the-world/ articleshow/ 45392663.cms
- Singh, S. R. 2014, October 10. Zuckerberg gets a taste of rural India. Business Line. https:// www.thehindubusinessline.com/ info-tech/ social-media/ Zuckerberg-gets-a-taste-of-rural-India/ article20884478.ece
- Soni, A., and Mallya, H. 2014, October 12. Mark Zuckerberg’s tryst with India, Modi and ‘Chandauli’. YourStory.Com. https:// yourstory.com/ 2014/ 10/ mark-zuckerberg-india-narendramodi
- ET Bureau. 2014, October 11. Mark Zuckerberg promises PM Narendra Modi mobile app for Clean India. The Economic Times. https:// economictimes.indiatimes.com/ tech/ internet/ markzuckerberg- promises-pm-narendra-modi-mobile-app-for-clean-india/ articleshow/ 44779335.cms
- Pahwa, N. 2014, October 10. What Mark Zuckerberg didn’t say about Internet.org. MediaNama. https:// www.medianama.com/ 2014/ 10/ 223-zuckerberg-india-internet-org/
- Facebook Newsroom. 2015, February 10. Internet.org App Now Available in India | Facebook Newsroom. https:// newsroom.fb.com/ news/ 2015/ 02/ internet-org-app-now-available-in-india/
- TRAI. 2015. Consultation Paper On Regulatory Framework for Over-the-top (OTT) services— Consultation Paper No.: 2/ 2015. Telecom Regulatory Authority of India. https:// main.trai.gov.in/ sites/ default/ files/ OTT-CP-27032015.pdf
- Baburajan K. 2015, March 30. Telecoms to lock horns with OTT players as TRAI brings consultation paper. TelecomLead. https:// www.telecomlead.com/ telecom-services/ telecoms-tolock- horns-with-ott-players-as-trai-brings-consultation-paper-57067
- Tribune. 2015, April 27. Telcos bat for licence regime for WhatsApp, Skype. Tribuneindia News Service. https:// www.tribuneindia.com/ news/ nation/ telcos-bat-for-licence-regime-forwhatsapp- skype/ 72992.html
- IANS. 2015, April 16. Odisha CM bats for net neutrality. Business Standard India. https:// www.business-standard.com/ article/ news-ians/ odisha-cm-bats-for-net-neutrality- 115041601396_1.html
- Varma, V. 2015, April 18. Tathagata Satpathy, an MP from Odisha, lends support for net neutrality. The Indian Express. https:// indianexpress.com/ article/ india/ india-others/ tathagatasatpathy- mp-from-odisha-lends-support-for-net-neutrality/
- Mukherjee, A. 2015, April 22. Rahul Gandhi bats for Net neutrality without being on social media. India Today. https:// www.indiatoday.in/ india/ story/ rahul-gandhi-net-neutrality-socialmedia- twitter-facebook-249763-2015-04-22
- Mishra, A. K. 2015, May 9. India’s Net neutrality crusaders. Livemint. https:// www.livemint.com/ Sundayapp/ FJQWrDereqsC3zGIEspGqI/ The-people-who-want-to-save-the- Internet.html
- AIB. 2015, April 11. AIB: Save The Internet. https:// www.youtube.com/ watch? time_continue=547&v=mf Y1NKrzqi0&feature=emb_logo
- TRAI. 2016. Prohibition of Discriminatory Tariffs For Data Services Regulation 2016. TRAI, Government of India. https:// trai.gov.in/ sites/ default/ files/ Regulation_Data_Service.pdf
- Jeffrey, R., and Doron, A. 2013. Cell Phone Nation. Hachette India.
- Mukherjee, R. 2019. Imagining Cellular India: The Popular, the Infrastructural, and the National. In A. Punathambekar & S. Mohan (Eds.), Global Digital Cultures: Perspectives from South Asia (pp. 76–95). University of Michigan Press. www.jstor.org/ stable/ j.ctvndv9rb.7
- Prasad, R. 2018. Ascendant India, digital India: How net neutrality advocates defeated Facebook’s Free Basics. Media, Culture & Society, 40(3), 415–431. https:// doi.org/ 10.1177/ 0163443717736117
- Jasanoff, S. 2015. Future Imperfect: Science, Technology, and the Imaginations of Modernity. In S. Jasanoff & S.-H. Kim (Eds.), Dreamscapes of Modernity: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and the Fabrication of Power. University of Chicago Press.
- Wynne, B. 1996. May The Sheep Safely Graze? A reflexive View of the Expert-Lay Knowledge Divide. In S. Lash, B. Sczerszynski, & B. Wynne (Eds.), Risk, Environment and Modernity: Towards a new ecology (pp. 44–83). Sage Publications.
- Collins, H., and Evans, R. 2007. Rethinking Expertise. University of Chicago Press.
- Miller, C. A. 2015. Globalizing Security: Science and the Transformation of Contemporary Political Imagination. In S. Jasanoff & S.-H. Kim (Eds.), Dreamscapes of Modernity: Sociotechnical Imaginaries and the Fabrication of Power. University of Chicago Press.
- Benkler, Y. 2006. The wealth of networks: How social production transforms markets and freedom. Yale University Press.
- PTI. 2015, December 20. 6 lakh comments on Trai’s second net neutrality consultation paper. Hindustan Times Tech. https:// tech.hindustantimes.com/ tech/ news/ 6-lakh-comments-on-trais- second-net-neutrality-consultation-paper-story-O5GBhMNpNAa1jcArdF6dDP.html
- Isin, E., and Ruppert, E. 2015. Being Digital Citizens. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
- Lyon, D. 2018. The Culture of Surveillance: Watching as a Way of Life. Wiley.
- Bauman, Z. 2007. Consuming LIfe. Polity Press.
- Zuckerberg, M. 2015, April 17. Mark Zuckerberg to HT: Net neutrality and universal connectivity must co-exist. Hindustan Times. https:// tech.hindustantimes.com/ tech/ news/ mark-zuckerbergto- ht-net-neutrality-and-universal-connectivity-must-co-exist-storyoViWLaARpJ5q5Pk5P4eCbL. html
- Rajan, N. 2015, October 28. Mark Zuckerberg at IIT-Delhi: Highlights of Facebook townhall. The Indian Express. https:// indianexpress.com/ article/ technology/ social/ live-facebook-ceomark- zuckerbergs-townhall-at-iit-delhi/
- Choudhary, V. 2016, January 8. Facebook spends around Rs300 crore on Free Basics ad campaign in India. Livemint. https:// www.livemint.com/ Consumer/ oMmTd2g4CkwErMNRoedVMJ/ Facebook-spends-around-Rs300-crore-on-Free-Basics-ad-campaig.html
- Quint. 2016, January 21. Free Basics Row: TRAI Red Flags Facebook’s ‘Orchestrated Poll’. The Quint. https:// www.thequint.com/ technology/ 2016/ 01/ 21/ free-basics-row-trai-red-flagsfacebooks-
- Smiley, L. 2016, February 1. How India Pierced Facebook’s Free Internet Program. Wired. https:// www.wired.com/ 2016/ 02/ how-india-pierced-facebooks-free-internet-program/
- Save The Internet. 2015, April 21. About Us. https:// web.archive.org/ web/ 20160608132224/ http:// blog.savetheinternet.in/ about/
- Kelty, C. 2005. Geeks, Social Imaginaries, and Recursive Publics. Cultural Anthropology, 20(2), 185–214.
- Irwin, A. 1995. Citizen Science: A study of people, expertise and sustainable development. Routledge.
- Irwin, A., and Wynne, B. 1996. Misunderstanding science? The public reconstruction of science and technology. Cambridge University Press.
- Zuboff, S. 2019. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. PublicAffairs.
- EU GDPR. 2020. What is a data subject? EU GDPR Compliant. https:// eugdprcompliant.com/ what-is-data-subject/
- Subramanian, V. 2020, July 10. How the TikTok phenomenon democratised online space in India. Moneycontrol. https:// www.moneycontrol.com/ news/ opinion/ how-the-tiktok-phenomenondemocratised- online-space-in-india-5531431.html
- Block, D. 2019, February 1. How Reliance Jio is monopolising the telecom sector. The Caravan. https:// caravanmagazine.in/ reportage/ government-helping-reliance-jio-monopolise-telecom
- Singh, M. 2020, June 24. India approves Facebook’s $5.7 billion deal with Reliance Jio Platforms. TechCrunch. https:// social.techcrunch.com/ 2020/ 06/ 24/ india-approves-facebooks-5- 7-billion-deal-with-reliance-jio-platforms/
- Internet.org. 2015, October 23. Where we’ve launched. English. https:// info.internet.org/ en/ story/ where-weve-launched/
- Bartlett, J. 2018. The People Vs Tech: How the internet is killing democracy (and how we save it). Ebury Publishing.
- Census of India. 2011. Census of India 2011: Language. Census of India. https:// www.censusindia.gov.in/ 2011Census/ C-16_25062018_NEW.pdf
- Internet Live Stats. 2016. India Internet Users. https:// www.internetlivestats.com/ internet-users/ india/
- MacKenzie, D. A., and Wajcman, J. 1999. The Social Shaping of Technology. Open University Press.
- Vijayakumar, S. 2015, May 9. Definition of Net Neutrality should be flexible: Pranesh Prakash. The Hindu. https:// www.thehindu.com/ business/ Industry/ pranesh-prakash-on-definition-ofnet- neutrality/ article7188661.ece